With specializations in Medical Anthropology & Anthropology of Higher Education, my work is a sustained inquiry into how individuals and communities make sense of their experiences within larger institutional and historical frameworks.
Using the cultural history of African American engagement with health and authoritative governance as a lens into understanding collective memory, premonition and fatalism inquiry, medicalization and knowledge delegitimization of midwifery practices, and reproductive injustice.
The complex ways in which higher education institutions and their culture shape the professional lives of faculty and the transformations using principles of adaptive organizational change to mobilize communities around problems, challenges and solutions.
Critical exploration of the concept of failure in scientific work, examining both societal and institutional factors that shape who is empowered to disclose failures.
Discovering epistemological bridges across ethnographic informed qualitative methodology and highly constrained interview modalities to privilege respondents’ ways of understanding and narrating illness experience in areas such as genetic knowledge, informed consent, prostate cancer and masculinity, breast cancer and self-blame, anatomy and embodied knowledge, and family history in the meaning-making and the decision-making process.
My work sheds light on how individuals navigate multiple sites of knowledge, negotiating contradictory ideas about health, citizenship, modernity, and inclusion, especially those shaped by the history of health governance and the rise of scientific medicine.
In my book, African American Midwifery in the South: Dialogues of Birth, Race, and Memory (Harvard University Press, 1988) I describe, through evidence from fieldwork and archival research, nearly four centuries of midwifery care as foundational to the health of rural African American mothers and children in the southern United States. I argue that public health professionals, in alliance with southern obstetric gynecologists and legitimized by the rising influence of eugenic science, criminalized African American midwifery practices. This criminalization disrupted the apprenticeship lineages through which successive generations had learned to provide culturally resonant reproductive care within their communities. The community members’ descriptions of midwifery cosmology and birthing practices—along with their complex, often ambivalent views on whether it was a loss or benefit to be included in or excluded from segregated birthing spaces in hospitals—painted a multifaceted picture of the changing landscape. Their pragmatism regarding the inevitable subordination of intrinsic knowledge or “mother wit” to the technical expertise of biomedicine reflected a nuanced reality that I have worked to convey.
Black women in the U.S. are far more likely to die from complications related to pregnancy and birth than White women. Two scholars explore how the discrediting of Black midwives helped create these racial disparities—and call for alternative models of prenatal care.
By DÁNA-AIN DAVIS AND KELLEY AKHIEMOKHALI, 29 AUG 2023
Black women: 49.5 deaths per 100,000 live births
White women: 19.0 deaths per 100,000 live births
Hispanic women: 16.9 deaths per 100,000 live births
Uncovering diverse perspectives on biomedical care, I challenged reductionist views that overlooked patient experiences and cultural contexts. While cultural competence was gaining attention in healthcare, I sought to expand beyond it, working with colleagues who proposed to develop research and training projects focused on deep-rooted disparities in care for minority populations. This contributed to a stronger ethical framework, particularly by providing deeper insights into how questions were posed and how participants’ stories were interpreted.
A key contribution was the development of ethnographic research designs and consulting on ethnographic interviewing and critical interpretive analysis. During data analysis, I advocated for a multi-perspective approach, contextualizing meaning across interviews.
A long-standing collaboration with Dr. Kerry Kilbridge, a genitourinary oncologist, was especially fruitful. We explored the communication gap between doctors and rural African American men at risk for prostate cancer. Initially, the issue seemed to be patient reluctance to discuss intimate issues, bearing on masculine identity and sexual embodiment, but the men with whom we talked wanted to discuss their illness with us and with other men in focus groups-- research revealed a deeper structural problem: a mismatch between medical jargon and patients' everyday language. This led to several papers highlighting the gap between "doctor talk" and patients' preferred terms, the goal was to help clinicians improve communication by using more accessible language and visual techniques. These collaborations bridged the gap between anthropology and clinical research, documenting the importance of metering what the participants called ‘doctor-talk’ and their preference for more explicit vernacular language.
Our research revealed a deeper structural problem: a mismatch between medical jargon and patients' everyday language. This led to several papers highlighting the gap between "doctor talk" and patients' preferred terms. The goal was to help clinicians improve communication by using more accessible language and visual techniques.
Anthropology has, to date, barely scratched the surface of the complex dynamics of the higher education academy, often overlooking the ways in which faculty life and careers are shaped by these structures and normative routines. As a result of my international exposure to comparative higher education system in Brazil, Mexico, Russia, South Africa, and across the US, on inter-agency leave from UVA, to work as a Ford Foundation Higher Education Program Officer, I gained a unique understanding of how universities were organized and managed change, particularly around incorporating previously excluded people.
On return to my home institution, I sought to catalyze change that would transform that which may have impeded faculty and the institution itself from achieving their highest ideals. Therefore, my research and knowledge innovation led to the creation of groundbreaking initiatives through community engaged scholarship.
Here I translated academic research into an exhibit incorporating texts from qualitative analysis of themes from oral history interviews, narratives based on archival historical research and a collaborative portraiture project based on co-created images between subjects and photographer. A towering 9 ft multi-walled installation was erected in the Chemistry Building and the Charles C Brown Engineering and Science Library. Between March 2017 to May 2017, it became a stop on campus tours for aspiring students, faculty candidates, and embraced by the campus community. For commemoration after the exhibit, an 82-page book was developed.
In the US, search committees are the entry point for faculty into the academy. They are, as some authors have argued, the “principal expression of academic values”. It is in the complex work of the search committee that any transformations in faculty recruitment, advancement, and the culture of the university is shaped. My research included a systematic review of the literature on search committees, interviews of colleagues at similar research institutions, and interviews with faculty who had been either members or chaired search committees at UVA. An anthropological informed qualitative analysis of the data led to the development of the Search Committee Tutorial and Search Tools Portal: a university-wide resource for faculty recruitment and hiring at UVA, and was later adopted nationally as a best practice resource for faculty recruitment and implemented at many U.S. institutions and universities including MA-HERC, a consortium of 57 institutions.
Institutional climate can have a negative impact on some members of the community while going unnoticed by others. Theatre, unlike daily interactions, is curated to prompt reflection and awareness, helping audiences see issues they might otherwise overlook. Interactive theatre, particularly in faculty development, helps participants recognize marginalization in everyday interactions. It fosters embodied problem-solving and shared meaning-making, building skills and dispositions for behavior change. The ADVANCE program used interactive theatre to engage faculty in reflection on issues of faculty recruitment, search committee evaluation, departmental cultural climate, equity in allocation of faculty service and rewards, ultimately changing institutional culture.
PAW is an institutional, extra-departmental effort deliberately structured as such to alleviate concerns that participants are being evaluated. The program was designed to foster conversations about the writing process, de-stigmatize the writing difficulties faced by many, and provide practical advice from U.Va. colleagues and nationally known experts on the practice of writing and academic publishing.
My new research, launched after an NSF conference on failure disclosure I organized in June 2024, explores the growing topic of failure disclosure in science. Recent scholarship suggests that transparency about failure can enhance public trust in STEM and provide valuable lessons to students and early-career professionals, showing that failure need not hinder career advancement. Advocates argue that scientists should avoid internalizing failure and instead use it as a stepping stone, fostering a more open, generative approach. This, they believe, could strengthen scientific communities and promote inclusivity and diversity. Some even suggest that scientists share "failure CVs" to normalize setbacks and cultivate resilience.
However, my research highlights that failure disclosure may not benefit everyone equally. A key focus will be examining how gender impacts access to the privileges of failure transparency. Oral histories from women in STEM show that many find it risky to openly discuss their failures, especially with peers, suggesting that societal and institutional factors influence who feels empowered to disclose failure. I aim to create opportunities for STEM practitioners to build communities and allyship networks where they can openly discuss failure and its meanings in their work. Additionally, I seek to identify institutional models that reward failure as a resource for innovation. Alongside the conference, I’ve organized an international network of failure scholars from the U.K., Poland, Nigeria, and the U.S., all working in critical failure studies.
Book: African American Midwifery in the South: Dialogues of Birth, Race, and Memory
Harvard University Press, 1998
Harnessing Ignorance? Resources for action and resistance during the covid-19 pandemic crisis in Nigeria Journal of the theoretical humanities vol 30 (2) 2025
Fatalism Knowledge and Inquiry in African American Family Stories of Death Premonition
American Anthropologist, 123: 318-329, 2021
Development of a Screening Tool to Assess Prostate Cancer Health Literacy
Journal of Clinical Oncology 35(6_suppl):127-127, 2017
Lack of Comprehension of Common Prostate Cancer Terms in an Underserved Population
Journal of Clinical Oncology, VOLUME 27 NUMBER 12 APRIL 20 2009
Inhalant Use Among Adolescents in the US: A Study of Contextual Concerns
Journal of Substance Use Volume 4, Issue 4. 170-177, 2009
Southern Online Journal for Nursing Research vol 8(3), 2008
Fracasopolicy: Toward a Critical Typology of Policy Failures
Globalizations, 1–18, 2024
Art for Institutional Change: Legitimizing Women in STEM Through Visibility
ADVANCE Journal, 2018
Faculty Diversity and Search Committee Training: Learning from a Critical Incident
Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 4(3)185-198, 2011
Discovery and Inquiry Pathways to Navigating the Routledge International Handbook of Failure
Routledge International Handbook of Failure.495-498, 2023
Workshop Design for Diversity and Dialogue: Women in STEM Empowered to Engage Across Difference
In Forward to Professorship in STEM Inclusive Faculty Development Strategies That Work , R. Heller, C. Mavripilis and P. Sabila (Eds.) pp.
107-127, 2015
As the daughter of Gladys Minnette, who migrated to the U.S. alone in the late 1960s, I have inherited a legacy of resilience. Though an experienced Social Welfare Officer and educator in Jamaica, Gladys first worked as a live-in domestic before retiring from the New York civil service as a DC37 municipal union treasurer. She earned her college degree, magna cum laude from Pace University. Her mother, Marie Wheatley Barnes, a dedicated Garveyite, was politically active in anti-Batista and Jamaican independence movements, splitting her time between Cuba and Jamaica. My great-grandmother, Susan Arbouin, born in 1845 (seven years after the emancipation of slavery), was a landowner and community leader in Kingston, Jamaica.
I come from a lineage of formidable, courageous women who have shaped my path; past and present. Thank you to my sister for being my powerful advocate—always encouraging me to see myself in new and empowering ways. Your support has been invaluable, and I’m so grateful for your unwavering belief in me. Much love to my daughter Maya, for carrying forward this powerful lineage. Your words and strength inspire me every day.